Tuesday, June 11, 2019

Challenges in tackling land issues in Cambodia


Challenges in tackling land issues in Cambodia

Khmer Times, Opinion, 11 June 2019
 
Cambodia is facing complex structural challenge to deal with land disputes. As the economy grows with high influx of capital investment ready to rip benefit from speculation and structural weaknesses of the land management system, tackling the land issues is becoming even more difficult.

The first Land Law was promulgated in 1992 and amended in August 2001. Cambodia has a dual land tenure system containing both ‘soft’ and ‘hard’ titles. Soft title applies to land rights that are registered by a local authority. Hard title applies to land rights registered by national level under the jurisdiction of the Land Management and Planning office. Cambodia aims to eventually register all the estimated 7 million land parcels with nationally recognized hard title by 2021. By the end of December 2018, around 5.1 million land titles were issued, which is equivalent to 73.25%.
In any land dispute, it is extremely difficult to identify who is the real victim. There are conflicts between the poor and the rich but there are also conflicts among the riches. For instance, an anecdote had it that a commune chief certified soft title over the same plot of land to two different tycoons. When asked why he did so, the commune chief told the court that he had no choice because he was threatened by two very powerful tycoons.

On another aspect, it does not mean to say that the poor are always the victims. There are some cases that certain individuals exploit the public sympathy by labelling themselves as the “poor” and “vulnerable” but in fact they are illegal land encroachers who stand on the mantra that say, “if you win, you get the land; if you lose, you will get the government’s compensation.”

Whenever there are land disputes, it is hard to find examples of successful resettlements owing to the involvement of many stakeholders. Sometimes the issues are politicized, demonized and victimized. So far, the settlement of the relocation of peoples from the White Building can be considered as a model for future redevelopment projects, where resolutions were smooth and acceptable by parties concerned.

In addressing land dispute, it is suggested that Cambodia should set a uniform standard formula to address those issues; however, such requirement is quite challenging- considering that different locations of lands would pose different sets of problems and resolutions, including the size of financial compensation and types of lands for resettlement.

Despite many structural challenges and limited capacity, coupled with challenges posed by social, economic and political externalities, many practical measures have been put into place to accelerate the resolution of the outstanding land disputes so as to provide justice for the people who are the real victims and to promote social harmony.

Concerning the dispute settlement mechanism, with the recent nomination of the Minister of Land Management to lead the National Authority of Land Conflict Resolution, Cambodia now has a single window to address all land disputes.

Regarding the economic land concessions (ELCs), a moratorium was put in place in 2012 owing to the understanding that some companies did not conducted investment activities as pledged and only created problems such as deforestation and forced evictions. After the review in February 2016, 23 of the 113 ELCs issued by the environment ministry had been revoked and other four companies had voluntarily handed their concessions back to the state. State also pledged nearly 1 million hectares of re-appropriated property to be handed over to the poor families.

Wednesday, April 24, 2019

ការ​អភិវឌ្ឍ​នៅ​ក្នុង​ខេត្ត​​ព្រះសីហនុៈ មាន​កង្វះ​ខាត​អត្តសញ្ញាណ​ខ្មែរ និង​បរិយាប័ន្ន




ភ្នំពេញប៉ុស្តិ៍ (ថ្ងៃទី ២៤ ខែមេសា ឆ្នាំ២០១៩)

ក្រុងព្រះសីហនុលែង​ជា​តំបន់​​​​ដែល​គ្មាន​ការ​អភិវឌ្ឍ​ និង​ជា​ឆ្នេរ​ដ៏ស្ងប់ស្ងាត់​សម្រាប់​ភ្ញៀវ​ទេសចរ​​​សាក់​កាដូ​ទៀត​ហើយ​។ តថភាព​​ថ្មី​នេះ ​គឺ​ជា​អ្វី​ដែល​យើង​គ្រប់​គ្នា​ស្វាគ​មន៍។​ ប៉ុន្តែការវិវត្ត​យ៉ា​ង​លឿន ​នៃ​ទីក្រុង​បាន​ជះឥទ្ធិ​ពល​សង្គមនិង​បរិស្ថាន​ដែល​មិន​អាច​មើ​ល​រំលង​បាន​។​ កង្វះខាត​ “អត្ត​​សញ្ញាណ​ខ្មែរ” និង​ “បរិយា​ប័ន្ន” គឺជា​បញ្ហា​ដែល​យើង​គួរ​តែ​ពិចារណា។

ទីក្រុង​ទាំងមូល​ស្ថិតនៅ​ក្នុង​ស្ថា​ន​ភាពកំពុង​សាងសង់ ជាមួយ​​​នឹង​ឡាន​ដឹក​ស៊ីម៉ងត៍ជាច្រើន​បរចុះឡើង​លើ​ផ្លូវ​ដែល​​មិន​ទាន់​ធ្វើ​រួច។ ​គ្រឿងយន្តស្ទូច​នៅពាសពេញ​ទីក្រុង ហាក់​កំពុង​ត្រៀ​ម​រៀបបន្តុប​អគារខ្ពស់ៗ​ពីមួយ​ទៅ​មួយ​​​។​
 
ទីក្រុង​ព្រះសីហនុ​បាន​​កែប្រែ​​ដល់​កម្រិត​មើល​លែងស្គាល់ ទៅ​ជា​ទីក្រុង​ដែល​ផុស​ផុល​ដោយ​ឧស្សា​ហកម្ម​សំណង់ និង​កាស៊ីណូ។

សម្រាប់​ប្រជាជន​ខ្មែរ​គ្រប់​រូប នៅ​ពេល​ដែលទៅ​ទស្សនា​ក្រុង​ព្រះសីហ​​​​នុ យើង​តែង​តែ​ចោទ​សួរ​ខ្លួន​ឯង​អំពី​​អត្ត​សញ្ញាណជាតិ​​របស់​ខ្លួន​​។​ ភាព​អន្ទះ​អន្ទែ​ង​កើតឡើង​ដោយ​សារ​សមត្ថ​ភា​ព​គ្រប់គ្រង​កំណើន​យ៉ាង​គំហុក​នៅមាន​កម្រិត​ និង​កង្វះខាត​អត្តសញ្ញាណខ្មែរ​នៅក្នុង​ដំណើរ​ការ​អភិវឌ្ឍ។​ ក្រុង​ព្រះសីហនុ​ត្រូ​វ​ទទួល​​ការ​ហូរ​ចូល​​យ៉ាង​គំហុក​​នូវ​មូលធន​នៅពេល​ដែល​ហេដ្ឋារ​ចនា​សម្ព័ន្ធរូ​បវន្ត​មូល​​ដ្ឋា​ន​នៅ​ពុំ​ទា​ន់​មាន​លទ្ធភាព​គ្រប់គ្រាន់​​នៅ​ឡើយ។

ទីក្រុង​ហុយដីនៅខែប្រាំង និង​មាន​ភក់ជ្រាំនៅខែវស្សា ជាមួយ​នឹង​ផ្លូវ​ដែល​ធ្វើ​មិន​ទាន់រួច។ ផ្លូវ​ខ្លះពុំ​ទាន់ត្រូវ​បាន​រៀបចំ​ដោយសារ​តែ​ការ​អភិវឌ្ឍ​ថ្មី​ពេក និង​លឿន​ពេក។ តម្រូវ​ការ​មូល​ដ្ឋាន​ដូច​ជា​ការ​គ្រប់​គ្រង​សំរាម លូទឹក​​កខ្វក់​ និង​ប្រព័ន្ធទឹក​ស្អាត​ បាន​កើ​ន​ហួ​ស​ពីកម្រិត​សមត្ថ​ភាព​ដើម​របស់​​ទីក្រុង។​

ផល​ប៉ះពាល់​អវិជ្ជមាន​ដែល​ផ្សារភ្ជាប់​ជាមួយ​នឹង​ឧស្សាហកម្ម​កាស៊ីណូ​ ក៏ជាបញ្ហាកង្វល់​រួម ដែល​សូម្បីតែ​ស្ថាន​ទូត​ចិន​ នៅ​កម្ពុជា ក៏ជារឿយៗ​តែង​តែ​អំពាវ​នាវ​ឲ្យ​មាន​ការ​ពង្រឹង​​ការអនុវត្ត​ច្បាប់ ដើម្បីការពារ​មុខមាត់​ចិន ដែ​ល​បាន​ចូលរួម​ចំណែក​ដល់​ការ​អភិវឌ្ឍ​របស់​កម្ពុជា។​

កង្វះខាត​អត្ត​សញ្ញាណខ្មែរ​​គឺបាន​ស្តែង​ចេញ​យ៉ាង​ច្បាស់​។​ ស្លាក​សញ្ញា​នានា​ ត្រូវ​បាន​សរសេរ​លើ​ផ្ទាំង​ពណ៌​ក្រហម​ ហើយ​ចាប់​ផ្តើម​ដោយ​ពាក្យ “ចុង​​គ័រ” ដែល​ប្រែថា “ប្រទេស ​ចិន”។ ស្លាក​សញ្ញា​ខ្លះ​បាន​សរសេរ​ខុស​អក្ខរា​​​​វិរុទ្ធខ្មែរ ដោយ​ចម្លង​ចេញ​ទាំងស្រុងពី Google-translate ដោយ​គ្មាន​ការ​ផ្ទៀងផ្ទាត់​ ហើយ​ឈ្មោះទាំង​នោះបែរ​ទៅ​ជា​មាន​ន័យ​ផ្សេង និង​ចម្លែក។

ទោះបី​ជាឆ្នេរ​សមុទ្រ​គឺជា​សម្ប​ត្តិ​សាធារណៈក្តីប៉ុន្តែពុំ​មាន​ហេដ្ឋារចនា​សម្ព័ន្ធ​គ្រប់​គ្រាន់​ដើម្បី​ឲ្យ​ប្រជាជន​ខ្មែរ​​ជាច្រើន​ស្រទាប់ អាច​មក​លំហែ​កាយ​បាន​ ឧទាហរណ៍​ដូចជា​កង្វះ​ខាត​សណ្ឋា​គារ ផ្ទះសំណាក់​និ​ង​ភោជ​នីយដ្ឋាន​ខ្មែរ ដែល​មាន​តម្លៃ​សមរម្យ​សម្រា​ប់​ប្រជា​ជន​ក្នុង​ស្រុក​ជាដើម។​

ការវិនិយោគ​ជាច្រើន​សន្ធឹក​សន្ធាប់​របស់​ចិន​ មាន​ធាតុ​ចូល​របស់​កម្ពុជា​តិច​តួច។​ ប្រជាជន​ខ្មែរ​ទទួល​ផល​ប្រយោជន៍​តែ​អំពី​​ការ​ជួល ឬទិញ​លក់​អចលនវត្ថុ​ ហើយផល​ទាំង​នេះទៀត​សោត ​មាន​តែ​ប្រជាជន​ដែល​មាន​អចលន​វត្ថុ​ប៉ុណ្ណោះ​ដែល​អាច​ទទួល​បាន​។ ផល​ប្រយោជន៍​ចេញ​ពី​តម្លៃ​បន្ថែម​នៃ​ការ​អភិវឌ្ឍ ​ក្រៅពីការជួល និង​ទិញ​លក់​អចលន​វត្ថុ​​ ​ហាក់ពុំ​ទាន់​បាន​រីក​សាយ​ភាយ​ដល់​ស្រទាប់​ប្រជាជន​ទូលំ​ទូលាយ​នៅ​ឡើយ។​

ក្រៅពីការងារ​ដែល​មិន​ត្រូវ​ការ​ជំនា​ញ យើង​ក៏ត្រូវ​ចោទសួរ​ថា តើ​ប្រជាជន​ខ្មែរ​មាន​ឱកាស​ទទួល​ការងារ​កម្រិត​​​គ្រប់​គ្រង​ ឬ​ការងារ​ជំនាញ​ ឬការងារ​វិស្វកម្ម​ បាន​កម្រិត​ប៉ុនណា​ពី​ការ​វិនិយោគ​របស់​ចិននៅ​ក្រុង​ព្រះសីហនុ​​? តើ​ផលិត​កម្ម​ក្នុង​ស្រុក​ ទាំង​ផ្នែក​ទន់ និង​ផ្នែក​រឹង ត្រូវបាន​ប្រើប្រាស់​ជាធាតុ​ចូល​បាន​ច្រើន​ប៉ុនណានៅក្នុង​ដំណើរ​​ការ​​អភិវឌ្ឍ​ទីក្រុង​ព្រះសីហនុ?​

ចំពោះសំណួរ​ខាងលើ អាច​មាន​ចម្លើយ​ថា​ មក​ពីកម្ពុជា​ខ្វះខាត​កម្មករ​ជំនាញ ប៉ុន្តែ ការលើក​ឡើង​បែប​នេះ​មិន​អាច​ផ្តល់​ទឡ្ហីករណ៍គ្រប់​គ្រាន់​ចំពោះ​តថភាព​បច្ចុប្បន្ន​ ដែល​ចិន​គ្រប់-​គ្រង​​សកម្ម​ភាព​សេដ្ឋកិច្ច​មូលដ្ឋាន​តាំងពី​ការ​លក់​គ្រឿង​ទេស​កំប៉ិក​កំប៉ុក រហូត​ដល់​ជាង​កាត់​សក់ អាហារដ្ឋាន​តាម​ផ្លូវ និង​គ្លីនិក​សុខភាព​នោះ​ទេ។​
ពិតណាស់​ថា យើង​ស្វាគមន៍​ការ​វិនិយោគរបស់​ចិន​ ដែល​បាន​មក​ដាស់​ទីក្រុង​មួយ​ ដែល​ធ្លាប់​តែ​​ដេក​លក់​ដោយ​គ្មាន​សកម្ម​ភាព​សេដ្ឋកិច្ច​ ប៉ុន្តែ ដំណើរការ​វិវត្ត​ហាក់ផ្តេក​ផ្តួល​​ទាំងស្រុង​ទៅ​លើ​យន្តការ​ទីផ្សារសេរី​ឬ​ដែល​សេដ្ឋវិទូ​​លោក​ អាដាម ស្មុីត ហៅ​ថា “​បាតដៃ​អរូបីរបស់​ព្រះ”។ ប្រសិន​បើយើង​គ្មាន​ ការ​គ្រប់​គ្រង​បាន​ល្អ​ និង​គ្មាន​ការ​បញ្ចូល​ឲ្យ​បាន​គ្រប់​គ្រាន់​​នូវ​ទស្សន​វិស័យ​របស់​កម្ពុជា​ យន្តការ​ទីផ្សារសេរី ឬ “បាតដៃអរូបី​របស់​ព្រះ" ក៏​​អាចប្រែ​​ក្លាយទៅ​ជា​ផល​​ប៉ះពាល់​មិន​​ល្អ​​ដល់​ផល​ប្រយោជន៍​ប្រជាជន​មូលដ្ឋាន​ដែរ។

យ៉ាង​ណា​មិញ​ បញ្ហា​ដែល​បាន​លើ​ក​ឡើង​ខាង​លើ​ពុំ​មែន​ជា​ការ​ពិភាក្សា​អំពីការ​បាត់​បង់​អធិបតេយ្យ​ភាព​ជាតិ​នោះ​ទេ ព្រោះថា សិទ្ធិសម្រេច​ និង​អំណា​ច​​អនុវត្ត​ច្បាប់​ គឺស្ថិត​នៅ​លើ​ដៃ​កម្ពុជា​ទាំងស្រុង​ ហើយ​បន្ថែម​លើ​នេះ ស្ថាន​ទូត​ចិន​នៅ​កម្ពុជាក៏តែង​តែ​ថ្កោ​ល​​ទោស​ជា​សាធារណៈ ចំពោះ​រាល់​សកម្ម​ភាព​ខុស​ច្បាប់​របស់​ចិន​នៅ​កម្ពុជា និង​បាន​ស្នើ​ឲ្យ​កម្ពុជា​ពង្រឹង​ការ​អនុវត្ត​ច្បាប់​ដើម្បី​ជួយ​ការពារ​មុខ​មាត់​ចិន ដែល​ខំ​ជួយ​អភិវឌ្ឍ​កម្ពុជា។​

Tuesday, April 23, 2019

Practical cooperation between Cambodia and US



Opinion, Khmer Times, 23 April 2019 (Link)

Cambodia-US bilateral relations should be viewed beyond the paradigm of a superpower’s geopolitical rivalry. It is the principle of Cambodia’s foreign policy that seeks to make friends with all whilst being an enemy to no one.

As a small state, without prejudice to the protection of sovereign independence and territorial integrity, Cambodia sees no interest in creating animosity against any powers or relying heavily on any single source of security or market access. In other words, Cambodia is implementing a hedging and diversification strategy.

Recently, the gradual and quiet increase of practical cooperation between Cambodia and the US provides strong hope for positive amelioration of bilateral ties. Those fields include, inter alia, humanitarian cooperation, cultural preservation, environmental protection, law enforcement and military cooperation. Functional cooperation is critical to restoring political and strategic trust.

Beyond the tit for tat, efforts from both sides to manage the relationship in difficult times should be recognized. It is normal for countries to have differences, but these should overshadow the entirety of the bilateral relationship. The win-win scenario for both sides is to narrow down the differences, while expanding the areas of functional cooperation. Pragmatism should matter much more than political ideology.

The early sign of warming ties arose from the resumption of cooperation in October 2018 on finding the remains of Prisoners Of War/Missing in Action (POWs/MIA) on humanitarian and compassionate grounds. Ann Mills-Griffiths, Chairman of the board and CEO of the National League of POW/MIA Families acknowledged Cambodia’s act of goodwill and considered the latter as a country of “Golden Standard of cooperation”.

The US has offered remarkable assistance for cultural preservation via the Preah Vihear Authority. Support for demining activities was not disrupted and educational exchanges remain vibrant. For Cambodian students, pursuing their higher education in the US is their dream as the US remains the leading country in terms of the quality of education and innovation.

In terms of military cooperation, in March 2019 Cambodia and the US signed a bilateral military cooperation agreement with the aim of strengthening ties in humanitarian affairs, education and military training.

In April 2019, Army commander Lieutenant General Hun Manet also visited the US on the invitation of US Brigadier General Jonathan Braga, commander of the Special Operations Command Pacific, to attend a Pacific Area Special Operation Conference. The visit marked a significant milestone in normalizing the troubled bilateral ties.

In the same month, National Police Commissioner Neth Savoeun also led a delegation to the US to sign the first memorandum of understanding (MoU) with the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) to promote cooperation in law enforcement against transnational crimes.

The US Agency for International Development (USAID) also supports the Greening Prey Lang project to conserve biodiversity and the ecological system of the forest, which is one of Southeast Asia’s last remaining lowland evergreen woodlands. Prey Lang was designated a protected wildlife sanctuary in May 2016.

Among various endeavours, Greening Prey Lang project deserves special attention in terms of how both countries can cooperate on the supposedly sensitive issues. It is a hard truth that deforestation remains a key issue for Cambodia.

The core moral of the story is that instead of criticizing and pondering on weaknesses that stemmed from limited institutional capacity, which is commonplace for any developing nation, the US is working together with and giving a helping hand to the Cambodian government.

The “name and shame” tactic does not work for Asian mentality. Such approach often provokes a vicious cycle of defensive retaliation that discourages intention to cooperate. Attacking each other’s weak points is not constructive and is the major obstacle for the spirit of mutual respect and cooperation.

Without discrediting the US’s support to advocacy activities, it would be mutually beneficial if the US could balance between supporting the means of advocacy and the means of delivery of state actors. The approach of the Greening Prey Lang project should be replicated in other areas of practical cooperation.

It is imperative that both countries need to mitigate the differences and widen understandings by capitalizing the spill-over effect from increased practical cooperation across various sectors. Inter-personal friendship and trust is also important. Hence frank and open dialogue between the leaders of the two countries need to be encouraged. Both countries should put the people’s interests first. In the eyes of many Cambodians, the US remains one of the most trustworthy friends.

Saturday, April 20, 2019

Sihanoukville: A Cambodian City Losing Its ‘Cambodian-ness’





Sihanoukville: A Cambodian City Losing Its ‘Cambodian-ness’

Unchecked development by Chinese investors has come at a cost, freezing out locals and changing the city’s character.

The Diplomat, April 20, 2019

 Sihanoukville, the coastal city and only deep sea port of Cambodia, is no longer a sleepy, undeveloped town for backpackers. This is a fact that should be welcome. But the rapid urbanization has caused social and environmental impacts that cannot be ignored. The lack of “Cambodian-ness” and “inclusiveness” is something that needs to be discussed.
The whole city is under construction, with cement trucks running across unfinished roads; large-scale cranes sweep across the whole city landscape ready to erect high-rise buildings one after another. At a very fast speed, the city has changed unrecognizably into a construction and casino boom town.

For any Cambodian, a visit to the city always sparks a soul-searching exercise. The frustration is caused by the city’s limited capacity to manage growth and the lack of Cambodian-ness in the development process.

Simply put, the city’s basic infrastructure was not ready to handle the abrupt influx of massive capital flows. The resulting development is anything but a livable city. It is dusty in the dry season and muddy in the rainy season, with bumpy, unfinished – and sometimes unpaved, due to new development — roads almost everywhere. Utility requirements in regards to waste management, sewage systems, and water supply have gone beyond the city’s original capacity.

The negative effects stemming from the ecosystem of the casino industry has also drawn concern even from the Chinese embassy in Cambodia, which frequently pleads for enhanced law enforcement to ensure the positive image of Chinese contribution to Cambodia’s development.
The lack of Cambodian-ness is self-evident in Sihanoukville.

Signboards are mostly in red, with name prefixes such as “zhong guo” or “China”; some signboards feature misspelled Khmer characters that shop-owners seemingly took directly from Google Translate, giving odd meanings to the names.

Although the beach and coast are public property, there is no sufficient supporting infrastructure — such as affordable hotels, guesthouses, and Khmer restaurants — for a wide range of Cambodians to enjoy their holidays and festivities here.

The huge investment from China manifests itself in little Cambodian content. Other than the benefit from rental fees and real estate speculation, which is reserved only for a limited number of Cambodian people with access to property, there are no success stories wherein local Cambodians across the socioeconomic spectrum can benefit from the value-added interest of the massive investment projects.

One needs to ask: Beyond the menial jobs that Chinese investments offer, how many mid-management level jobs or skilled labor or engineering work do Cambodians have access to? How many local products, both hard and soft, are being used within the development process of Sihanoukville city?

It can be argued that Cambodia lacks the skilled labor to support Chinese investment but such an argument cannot provide sufficient explanation for the way that Chinese are dominating the local economy even in small grocery shops, hair salons, street food, and health clinics.

While Chinese investment has been able to wake up the sleeping town, the process has been left to the mercy of the free market economy — the so-called “invisible hand of God.” Without proper management and a clear projection of Cambodian vision, the free market economy can also turn into the “invisible hand of the devil” at the cost of local people’s interest.

With all the above issues notwithstanding, this is not a case of a loss of sovereignty; clearly the right to decide and authority to enforce the law are totally on the Cambodian side. Moreover, it is an undisputable fact that the Chinese embassy in Cambodia has publicly denounced all illegal acts committed by Chinese in Cambodia and requested stronger law enforcement to ensure that China can protect its good image in terms of positive contribution to Cambodia’s development.

Still, there is a need to ensure that China’s massive investment benefits both Cambodia and China, and that a wide strata of Cambodian people receive the fruit from this rapid development. With all the issues raised, now the questions is how to do this: How to ensure the Cambodian-ness of development and to project Cambodian vision in Sihanoukville? How to ensure more inclusiveness in that development?

Indeed, practical solutions exist, but these require flexible and innovative approaches to governance and development.

As Cambodia aspires to welcome ASEAN leaders in 2022 in Sihanoukville, the current magnitude of development challenges is probably too huge to be handled by the limited institutional capacity of the provincial government. If Cambodia is to develop Preah Sihanouk province into a multipurpose Special Economic Zone, an interministerial committee that is action-oriented and headed by a prominent figure that can coordinate and bulldoze over interministerial bureaucracy is urgently needed.

This committee should have the teeth and power to implement and decide the “development destiny” of the whole Preah Sihanouk province, especially the acceleration of development of public infrastructure such as roads, sewage system, water supply, and waste management. Perhaps local grown knowhow such as the APSARA authority, which oversees the sustainable development of Angkor heritage, can be an inspiration.

In terms of urban planning, there should also be a clear zoning policy for casino areas, family recreational areas, and industrial zones. The city should work to ensure that more public space can be enjoyed by local people with proper supporting facilities such as affordable hotels and Khmer restaurants.

Although it is hard to do in a free market economy, Cambodia should also have policies to limit foreign business activities that can harm local micro-enterprises.

In terms of enhancing institutional capacity for law enforcement, there is reason to hope for improvement with the recent visit of Interior Minister Sar Kheng to China and of Police Commissioner Neth Savoeun to the United States.

Financial regulation and better taxation should also be enhanced to ensure that Cambodia as a whole can benefit beyond rental fees and real estate speculation.

The development of Preah Sihanouk province should not become an example of failure to ensure the Cambodian-ness and inclusiveness of development. To that end, the responsibility falls heavily on the Cambodian side in terms of law enforcement and concrete implementation of national development policies.
Sim Vireak is Strategic Advisor of the Asian Vision Institute (AVI) based in Phnom Penh.

Thursday, March 28, 2019

Cambodia: Between ‘democracy’ and ‘development’


Cambodia: Between ‘democracy’ and ‘development’
Sim Vireak / Khmer Times,

March 28, 2019

Cambodia has a vision to become an upper-middle-income country by 2030 and a high-income economy by 2050. Nonetheless, this vision has met many distractions both domestically and internationally. Many expectations and concerns have been expressed relating to Cambodia’s future, as a vibrant democracy with a flourishing economy.

Despite being a fast growing economy and great achiever of the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs), Cambodia is still a young country in terms of demography and state building. These structural challenges cannot be taken for granted.

For instance, while health insurance is a matter of course for many countries, the public health insurance system in Cambodia is still in its nascent stage after its establishment in 2016 under the National Social Security Fund. This March, Cambodia just launched the construction of its first ever expressway linking Phnom Penh to Sihanoukville port. In Southeast Asia, Cambodia is probably the last country to have an expressway.
. .
In terms of demography, almost half of the population had been wiped out due to wars, putting the country into an extreme shortage of capable middle management in the 40 to 50 age category in both the private and public sector. This middle management is very critical for the current stage of Cambodia’s development and lack of this is causing structural underperformance.

As Cambodia endeavours to realise its ambitious vision, the country is currently struggling between perceptions that either puts first “democracy” or “development”. The perennial question is which should come first?

When the government keeps explaining the state of democracy and human rights of the country, the opposition group keeps pushing foreign governments and parliaments for various forms of diplomatic and economic pressures and punishments.

When the country is fighting the war of perception on whether Cambodia is democratic enough, the country struggles physically to build its water treatment system in Preah Sihanouk province to prevent sewage flowing directly to the sea or to save Boeung Trabek sewage canal from overflowing with garbage right in the middle of the capital Phnom Penh.

When the EU is pressing Cambodia on the Everything-but-Arms (EBA) issue, the country is struggling to find alternatives to cope with drought that is causing shortages of water and electricity. When some countries assure Cambodia of non-interference, some are seeking reversal of the Supreme Court’s decisions. Some people even made politicized comment to His Majesty the King, which is the country's symbol.


. .
The dilemma and ironies that Cambodia is facing seems troubling.

As a matter of fact, Cambodia needs both democracy and development but striking a balance is extremely hard especially when external actors are involved. One argument suggests that in order to become a vibrant democracy, Cambodia needs to build a “safe democracy” with a “credible opposition”. The definition of a “safe democracy” and “credible opposition” can vary but it needs to address both angles of the discussion.

“Safe democracy” should be a democracy that is safe for the opposition or groups of different persuasions and ideologies to express themselves without persecution. However, on the other hand it should also be a democracy that is safe from foreign interference and undemocratic regime change.
“Credible opposition” should mean an opposition that can provoke policy-based civilized dialogues in parliament instead of provoking street riots and vandalism. Real democracy is exercised in the National Assembly through policy consultation and debates, and not on the streets.

Extremist ideologies that incite class struggle, rebellion against state authorities, anti-Chinese and anti-Vietnamese racism, a revision of private ownership, revisionist approaches on borders in contrary to the principles of Uttis Possidetis and international laws shall be strictly prohibited.
. .
Amid such distraction, Cambodia needs to be focused more on its own vision of building a prosperous country that benefits all sectors of society. In the meantime, Cambodia also needs to continue improving social justice and inclusiveness, building a safe democracy with a credible opposition not because other countries say so but because its Constitution requires it.

Cambodia needs to be consistent in its principal positions and stay firm with regards to its independence and sovereignty on its democratic path. Building a mature democracy is a long-term process which requires participation from the people and all political parties.
International communities should continue to extend support to Cambodia’s “longest peace in modern history”, evolution towards peaceful and safe democracy and progress towards inclusive and sustainable development.

Regime change should not be an indicator of success or key performance index for any diplomatic missions. What Cambodia really needs now is to maintain high economic performance so that the middle class will become the key driving force in sustaining socio-economic development as well as strengthening democratic foundations. Social justice, the foundation of peace and stability, will need to be improved and judicial reform is a matter of urgency.

Sim Vireak is strategic advisor to Asian Vision Institute (AVI) based in Phnom Penh.